FREE Worldwide Shipping! | +1 365 654 6605


Your Cart is Empty

The Art of Cookie Cutting: Before or After Baking?

The Art of Cookie Cutting: Before or After Baking? - Maria's Condo

Baking cookies is an art that requires not just the right ingredients, but also the right techniques. One question that often arises when making shaped cookies is whether to use the cookie cutters before or after baking.


A Common Dilemma

Firstly, let's address the question at hand. Should you cut out your cookies before or after they've been baked? The answer may surprise you, as it isn't as straightforward as you might think.

Cutting Cookies Before Baking

The traditional method, and the one most commonly used, is to cut out your cookies before they go into the oven. This method allows you to shape your cookies exactly as you want them, and they will generally hold their shape during baking.

However, there are a few potential drawbacks. Cookies have a tendency to spread during baking, which can distort the shapes you've carefully cut out. This can be particularly frustrating when you're trying to create detailed or intricate designs.

There are ways to combat this, though. One is to refrigerate the dough before cutting and baking, as the cold dough will spread less. Another is to use a recipe specifically designed for cut-out cookies, as these doughs are typically stiffer and less prone to spreading.

Cutting Cookies After Baking

An alternative method that is gaining popularity is to cut out your cookies after they've been baked. This approach can give you perfectly shaped cookies every time, as there is no risk of the cookies spreading or losing their shape in the oven.

The key to this method is to roll out your dough and bake it as a single large cookie. As soon as it comes out of the oven, you use your cookie cutters to cut out your shapes. The residual heat makes the cookies easy to cut, and you'll get clean, sharp edges every time.

This method does require you to work quickly, as the cookies will harden as they cool, making them harder to cut. You'll also have some cookie scraps left over, although these can certainly be put to good use (or enjoyed as a baker's treat!).

The Best of Both Worlds

So, which method is best? As with many baking dilemmas, the answer depends largely on your personal preferences and the specific recipe you're using.

However, there is a third option that combines the best of both methods. This involves cutting your cookies out before baking, but then re-cutting them immediately after they come out of the oven. This allows you to get the precise shapes you want, but with the added reassurance of perfect, sharp edges.

To do this, simply follow the same steps as for cutting cookies after baking. After the cookies have been baked and while they're still hot, use the cookie cutter to cut the cookies again. This will give you the clean, sharp edges that are characteristic of the post-baking method.

Essential Tips for Using Cookie Cutters

Regardless of when you choose to cut your cookies, there are a few tips that can make the process easier and more successful.

Choose the Right Dough

Not all cookie doughs are created equal, and some are better suited to cut-out cookies than others. For the best results, choose a dough that is firm and not too sticky. This will make it easier to roll out and cut, and the cookies will hold their shape better during baking.

Use Quality Cookie Cutters

The quality of your cookie cutters can also make a big difference. Metal cutters are generally sharper and will give you cleaner edges than plastic ones. They can also be easier to handle, as they're less likely to warp or bend.

Roll Your Dough Evenly

When rolling out your dough, aim for an even thickness. This will ensure that your cookies bake evenly, and it will also make it easier to cut out your shapes. You can use a rolling pin with adjustable rings to help achieve the perfect thickness.

Keep Your Cutters (and Dough) Cold

If you're cutting your cookies before baking, try chilling your cookie cutters before use. This can make it easier to cut through the dough, and the cold metal can also help the cookies hold their shape better in the oven.

As mentioned earlier, chilling your dough can also be beneficial. Cold dough is easier to work with and less likely to spread during baking.

Work Quickly

If you're cutting your cookies after baking, remember to work quickly. The cookies will begin to harden as soon as they come out of the oven, so you'll need to cut your shapes while they're still hot.

Be Gentle

Finally, be gentle when handling your cut-out cookies. They can be quite delicate, especially when they're still warm. Use a thin spatula to lift them off the baking sheet, and allow them to cool completely before decorating.

In Conclusion

So, should you use cookie cutters before or after baking? The answer is, it depends on your personal preference and the type of cookies you're making. Both methods have their pros and cons, and you might find one works better for you than the other.

But regardless of when you choose to cut your cookies, remember that the most important thing is to have fun and enjoy the process. After all, isn't that what baking is all about?


  1. Can I Cut Out Cookies After They Have Baked? - Cake Central
  2. Can You Use Cookie Cutters on Sticky Dough? - Stack Exchange
  3. Trick for Sugar Cookies that Keep Their Shape - Chica and Jo
  4. Do You Use Cookie Cutters the Hard Way or the Easy Way? - The Goldilocks Kitchen
  5. Using Cookie Cutters - Cooking Tips

Marias Condo
Marias Condo

Also in Kitchen

Innovative Carrot Peelers: A Guide to the Latest Gadgets - Maria's Condo
Innovative Carrot Peelers: A Guide to the Latest Gadgets

December 08, 2023 4 min read

Smart Kitchen Gadgets for Carrot Lovers - Maria's Condo
Smart Kitchen Gadgets for Carrot Lovers

December 08, 2023 4 min read

How to Store Carrots for Long-Lasting Freshness - Maria's Condo
How to Store Carrots for Long-Lasting Freshness

December 08, 2023 4 min read