A Comprehensive Guide to Biscuit Cutters vs Cookie Cutters

Baking is an art that requires precision, creativity, and the right tools. Two essential tools often found in a baker's arsenal are biscuit cutters and cookie cutters. While they may seem similar at a glance, they have distinct differences and unique uses. This article will dive deep into the world of biscuit cutters and cookie cutters, dissecting their characteristics, uses, and potential substitutes.

 

Biscuit Cutter: An Overview

Biscuit cutters are specialized tools used predominantly in North America to cut dough into round shapes for biscuits, which are similar to British scones but without the high sugar content. They are often round with a taller cutting edge than a cookie cutter.

Material and Design

Biscuit cutters can be made of various materials, including plastic, nylon, stainless steel, and tin. The edges can be straight or fluted, although the fluted edges might not always leave an impression after baking.

Using a Biscuit Cutter

To prevent sticking, it's recommended to dip the biscuit cutter in flour before each cut. Press straight down into the dough without twisting to avoid pinching the dough, which can prevent the layers from separating and cause the biscuits to rise less in the oven.

Cookie Cutter: An Overview

Cookie cutters, on the other hand, are designed to cut and shape cookie dough into decorative shapes. They are often more intricate than biscuit cutters, coming in a multitude of shapes and sizes, such as hearts, stars, and animals.

Material and Design

Cookie cutters are often made of food-safe materials such as plastic or stainless steel Their designs are typically more ornate than biscuit cutters, allowing bakers to create decorative cookies for various occasions.

Using a Cookie Cutter

While it is technically possible to use biscuit cutters with cookie dough, it's not recommended. Biscuit cutters are typically larger than cookie cutters and may result in cookies that are too thick and not evenly baked

Comparing Biscuit Cutters and Cookie Cutters

While both biscuit cutters and cookie cutters serve the purpose of cutting dough into desired shapes, there are key differences between them.

Shape and Design

Cookie cutters often come in a wide variety of shapes and designs, allowing for more creativity in baking. Biscuit cutters, however, are usually round and come in a smaller range of sizes

Size

Biscuit cutters are generally larger than cookie cutters. This is because biscuits are typically thicker and larger than cookies

Usage

While biscuit cutters are specifically designed for cutting biscuit dough, cookie cutters can be used for a wider range of baking projects, including cookies, pastries, and even crafting

Biscuit Cutter Substitutes

If you find yourself without a biscuit cutter, there are several handy substitutes you can use:

Upside-Down Glass

An upside-down glass can serve as a simple and effective biscuit cutter substitute. It is best to choose a glass with a thin rim to cut through the dough.

Commercial Product Cans

Empty cans from food products can also be used as biscuit cutter substitutes. Both ends of the can should be removed, and the can should be thoroughly washed before use.

Cookie Cutter

A cookie cutter can be used as a biscuit cutter substitute, but it's important to choose one with high sides.

Knife

A very sharp knife can also be used to cut biscuits. This method allows for more creativity, as you can cut the biscuits into any shape you want.

Pizza Cutter

A pizza cutter can be a safe and effective tool for cutting biscuit dough.

Cookie Cutter Substitutes

If you don't have a cookie cutter on hand, there are several alternatives you can use:

Biscuit Cutter

As previously mentioned, a biscuit cutter can be used as a cookie cutter substitute, although the resulting cookies may be thicker and less ornate.

Commercial Product Cans

Just like with biscuits, cans can be used to cut cookie dough into simple shapes.

Knife or Pizza Cutter

A sharp knife or pizza cutter can be used to cut cookie dough into squares, rectangles, or other geometric shapes.

The Bottom Line

While biscuit cutters and cookie cutters may seem similar, they each have unique characteristics and uses. The key difference lies in their design, size, and the type of dough they're intended for. However, in a pinch, there are several household items that can be used as substitutes for both. Happy baking!

Footnotes

1. CooksInfo 

2. Adsy 

3. KitchenFeeds 

4. Eating Expired